Shoes were a little off from description. I know they are used and expected the "normal" wear and tear. Came in with some "sticky" residue though, looks like some glue of some sort so it wasn't necessarily "clean". It was sticky and collected dust easily. I can tell the shoes were restored to some degree, which is great. Shoe was "clean" otherwise, even did a smell test and it passed easily. I would honestly have left a negative review for the "glue" but I was able to clean some of it.